Tuesday, April 10, 2007

More fun with double standards.

Don Imus is an idiot. He thinks so. We all think so. So let's get that out of the way.

In the wake of the "nappyheaded hos" comment are Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson leading the public relations charge to have the man fired. What peeves me is that these two black leaders are very selective about what offends them. When Don Imus makes a comment like he does, he should be fired. When Michael Richards goes on a tirade, he should be...I don't know, crucified. Whatever. I'm inclined to agree. But what about 50 cent? Or Jay Z? Al Sharpton has stated many times before that he doesn't particularly care for their use of the "n word" either, but the only time you hear him say so is when he's specifically asked about the double standard. There are no marches. There are no press conferences. Hell, there aren't even any press releases. If racial slurs like these are offensive to you, then it shouldn't only offend you when Don Imus or Michael Richards say it. Matter of fact, it should be more offensive when someone of your own race tosses the word around so flippantly.

What really gets me though is a comparison of Al Sharpton's reaction to Don Imus's comments and his reaction to Ralph Nader's racial slur from two years ago. Yeah--Nader. In all likelihood, you never even heard about it because the New York Daily News was practically the only paper that ran the story (the link to the original story is gone). Nader was commenting on campaigning in Georgia:

Speaking Wednesday night at a Washington fund-raiser to retire the debt from his 2004 presidential campaign, Nader complained that Democratic Party powerbrokers had kept him off the ballot in such Southern states as Georgia and Virginia - which reminded him of the oppressive Jim Crow laws that denied African-Americans equal rights.

"I felt like a [n-word]," remarked the 70-year-old white multimillionaire graduate of Princeton University and Harvard Law School.
Not so much as a whimper from the black community. No marches. No protests. Al Sharpton basically just told Nader to refrain from use of the word in the future. From Sharpton:

"If Ed Koch had said what Ralph Nader said, we'd be marching," Sharpton noted. "This [scolding] doesn't rise to the level of a march. It rises to the level of a wrist slap."

Oh, okay. If Ed Koch said it, then it would be offensive. If it's your buddy Ralph, then no one need care.

Here's what this comes down to. I have no doubt that the n-word is offensive. I truly wish it were stricken from our vocabulary. But when I see Don Imus get the third degree and Ralph Nader get a Get-Out-of-Jail-Free card, I conclude that the big huzzah is grounded less in changing behaviors and more political tactic. You can't just get mad about it when it's people that are your political enemies. Otherwise, the rest of us have no reason to take your anger seriously and the whole thing is self-defeating.

Labels:

4 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

The two incidents don't compare. Ignorance and bravado are one thing. Hurtfulness toward others is yet another issue.

Nader spoke about himself, not others. If Imus had used his crude language on the air to talk about himself, he wouldn't have landed in the hotwater he rightly has for having used it while talking about someone else.

Tue Apr 10, 01:54:00 PM CDT  
Blogger Your Friendly Neighborhood Clark Bar said...

Fully granted. I don't think that there is any context in which the word is acceptable, but some are certainly worse than others. What bothers me about it is Sharpton's statement that if it were Koch, then they'd start the marches.

BTW, what's with the anonymous bit?

Tue Apr 10, 03:38:00 PM CDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow, apparently we have Carroll debater ESP or something because I also just wrote about this mess (a different take on it, but pretty much jives with what you just said).

All I can is that I very much agree. :)

Wed Apr 11, 06:00:00 PM CDT  
Blogger melissa o said...

HELLO - may I comment. If blacks are allowed to say those type of things about themselves and to each other because they ARE black - then let's give Don Imus a break because if anyone knows about being a "nappy-headed ho" THAT would be Don Imus - I am just saying...

Don Imus, yes, is an idiot - but let's be honest - who has put him on the air all these years and laughed to themselves as his antics raised ratings...hmmm. It's almost as if CBS/MSNBC were asking for it. So when Don Imus says "nappy-headed ho's" the world drops its collective pants.

Mon Apr 16, 08:28:00 AM CDT  

Post a Comment

<< Home